My Medium friends can enjoy this story here as well.

If you’re highlighting everything but remembering nothing, you’re not alone.

Here’s why most knowledge management systems actually make you forget more — and what to do instead.

We’ve all been there.

You discover an amazing article, start highlighting every brilliant insight, save it to your “second brain,” and feel incredibly productive. You’re building this massive knowledge vault that’s going to transform your thinking.

But then what happens? When you actually need those insights for a project or conversation… you can’t remember any of it.

Sound familiar? You’ve got thousands of highlights sitting in Readwise, browser bookmarks that would make a digital hoarder jealous, and Kindle notes you haven’t looked at in months.

We convince ourselves we’re learning, but really?

We’re just digital hoarding.

The science behind why this happens is fascinating.

When we highlight without processing, we’re essentially outsourcing our memory to external tools.

Psychologists call this the “Google effect” — our brains literally decide not to store information when they know it’s easily accessible elsewhere.

This challenge is especially acute for knowledge workers who consume more information than previous generations. Most of us treat our brains like hard drives when they actually work more like muscles.

They need resistance to grow stronger.

That constant highlighting? It’s like watching someone else do push-ups and expecting to get ripped.

The uncomfortable reality? Your brain isn’t designed to be a storage device. It’s designed to be a thinking machine.

So how do we break free from this highlighting addiction?

1. The 24-Hour Rule Force yourself to summarize key insights within 24 hours. No exceptions. Your brain has to work to reconstruct the idea, which creates actual memory. It’s like the difference between copying notes and explaining the concept to a friend.

2. The Connection Test Ask yourself: “How does this connect to something I already know?” If you can’t make that connection immediately, the highlight probably won’t stick anyway.

3. The Teaching Filter Only save what you could confidently explain to someone else right now. This simple test cuts out about 80% of mindless highlighting. Yeah, it’s brutal, but it works.

4. The One-Thing Principle Limit yourself to capturing one key insight per article or book. Sounds restrictive? Good. Constraints force deeper thinking.

Remember that feeling when you used to actually remember what you read?

When insights would pop up naturally in conversations? That’s what happens when you stop feeding your brain more inputs and start demanding better outputs.

The research is clear: forcing your brain to work with information, rather than just storing it, creates lasting memory.

The difference isn’t just noticeable — it’s transformative.

Stop chasing the perfect capture system. Start building a thinking system.

What’s one insight you’ve highlighted recently that you could explain right now without looking it up? Try it — you might be surprised by the answer.

-Matt

If you enjoyed this read, the best support I could receive would be if you shared it.

​Join a network of almost 1400 subscribers and followers who are finding and discovering new ways to get more time back to do what they love, with those they love today.

​Get 20% off forever​

As a thank you for making it this far, you may be still figuring out your path as a creative and that’s okay too. If you need a little boost, make sure to use promo code SUBSTACK30 to get 30% off my Niche Navigator GPT.

​